Patty Smyth was considered as a replacement for David Lee Roth in Van Halen in 1985. Michael Anthony looks back on the offer Eddie Van Halen made to the Scandal singer before Sammy Hagar joined the band.
Eddie Van Halen offered Patty Smyth the job
Speaking on November 15 at the Rock ’n’ Roll Fantasy Camp in Hollywood, California, Anthony said the idea came from Eddie. Roth’s departure had caught the band off guard. According to the bassist, Warner Bros. even wanted the musicians to change the band’s name in hopes that Roth would return.
Anthony said the band ultimately dropped the idea. “Bringing in a girl to sing songs about girls just wasn’t going to work.”
In a 2020 interview with Stereogum, Smyth said she was pregnant, couldn’t see herself living in Los Angeles, and thought the band drank heavily. She would have agreed to make a record with Eddie, though, if he’d asked.
Van Halen eventually brought in Sammy Hagar. Released in 1986, 5150 became the band’s first album to top the Billboard 200.
Van Halen’s final years and the proposed Eddie tribute tour
Van Halen played their final show on October 4, 2015, at the Hollywood Bowl, with Roth on vocals and Wolfgang Van Halen on bass. While Eddie was still alive, the band considered a tour that would have brought together Roth, Hagar, and Anthony, among others. According to Wolfgang, his father’s declining health kept the tour from happening. Anthony has since said he regrets how the band ended.
After Eddie’s death in 2020, Alex Van Halen and Roth discussed another tour with Joe Satriani. In a 2024 interview with Rolling Stone, Alex said the plan fell apart over a disagreement about how to honor Eddie at the shows. According to the drummer, Roth opposed including a tribute during the show. The singer’s representative disputed that account in comments to People.
Wolfgang also spoke about the tensions that made it difficult to organize a joint tribute. Hagar and Anthony played Van Halen songs with Satriani on The Best Of All Worlds tour.




The conversation 0
Different voices. A shared love of heavy music.
Be the first to share your thoughts.
What stands out to you? Start the conversation.
Join the conversation
Keep it thoughtful and respectful. Comments are reviewed before appearing.