Slayer, High on Fire and Gojira have all won the Grammy for Best Metal Performance. From Metallica’s first trophy in 1990 to Gojira’s win in 2025, here are ten of the heaviest bands to have triumphed in the category.
From Metallica’s First Grammy to Slayer’s Back-to-Back Wins
Metallica. In 1989, Jethro Tull beat Metallica in a category that still combined hard rock and metal. The following year, the California band won the first Grammy for Best Metal Performance with One, from that same album, …And Justice for All. They won again in 1991 with a cover of Queen’s Stone Cold Crazy.
Black Sabbath. Thirty years after the release of Paranoid, a live version of Iron Man earned the Birmingham band their first Grammy in 2000. Black Sabbath returned to the winners’ list in 2014 with God Is Dead?, from 13.
Motörhead. In 2005, Lemmy and his bandmates took home the trophy with Whiplash. Their cover reaches back to Metallica’s debut album, Kill ’Em All.
Slipknot. Previously nominated in 2001 for Wait and Bleed, the Iowa band won their first Grammy five years later. It was Before I Forget, from Vol. 3: (The Subliminal Verses), that earned them the award.
Slayer. The thrash band won two years in a row, with Eyes of the Insane in 2007, followed by Final Six in 2008. Both tracks come from Christ Illusion, with the latter added to the album’s reissue.
From Megadeth to Gojira
Megadeth. Dave Mustaine’s band had already been in contention in 1991 with Rust in Peace. Their first Grammy came in 2017 for the title track from Dystopia.
Mastodon. In 2007, Colony of Birchmen lost out to Slayer. The Atlanta band won in 2018 with Sultan’s Curse, the opening track on Emperor of Sand.
High on Fire. Electric Messiah earned Matt Pike’s trio the 2019 Grammy. Deafheaven and Between the Buried and Me were also nominated that year, with Honeycomb and Condemned to the Gallows.
Body Count. After a nomination for Black Hoodie in 2018, Ice-T’s band won the award in 2021 for Bum-Rush, from Carnivore.
Gojira. Performed at the Conciergerie during the opening ceremony of the Paris 2024 Olympics, Mea Culpa (Ah! Ça ira!) earned the French band their first Grammy in 2025. Gojira share the award for this adaptation of a revolutionary song with mezzo-soprano Marina Viotti and composer Victor Le Masne.
Megadeth and Mastodon are once again in contention for the 2027 Grammy for Best Metal Performance, with Let There Be Shred for the former and Your Ghost Again for the latter.




The conversation 0
Different voices. A shared love of heavy music.
Be the first to share your thoughts.
What stands out to you? Start the conversation.
Join the conversation
Keep it thoughtful and respectful. Comments are reviewed before appearing.