Skip to content
INDEPENDENT VOICES. HEAVY MUSIC.
About usSign in ↗
News

Every Dream Theater album ranked from worst to best

Every Dream Theater album ranked from worst to best© Marko Zamrznuti tonovi / Shutterstock.com
THE STORY

Dream Theater have been exploring progressive metal since the late 1980s. The American band have often switched formats, moving between relatively straightforward songs and albums that tell a story from start to finish. Some of the records that sit next to each other in this ranking have surprisingly little in common.

The strength of the songs and the way they flow into one another shaped the ranking, as did each album’s place in the band’s career. And then there are the records you still want to put on years after they came out…

16. The Astonishing (2016)

It takes Dream Theater 34 tracks and more than two hours to tell the story of a rebellion in a futuristic empire. There are even bagpipes on The X Aspect. The sheer scale of the project is fascinating, though some of its best moments get lost among the songs that move the plot along.

15. When Dream And Day Unite (1989)

Much of the debut dates back to when the band were still called Majesty. It’s also their only studio album with Charlie Dominici on vocals. Terry Brown, a longtime Rush collaborator, prepared the radio edits of Status Seeker and Afterlife. The main reason to revisit the album is to hear what was already taking shape in the songwriting.

14. Dream Theater (2013)

By the time of this self-titled album, Mike Mangini has settled in and the band are aiming for shorter songs. They still set aside around 20 minutes for Illumination Theory, the five-part suite that closes the album and features a string ensemble. Elsewhere, the playing is polished and the songs leave less of an impression.

13. Falling Into Infinity (1997)

The label pushes Dream Theater to write shorter songs with a shot at radio play. In the studio, producer Kevin Shirley cuts the middle section from Burning My Soul. It becomes Hell’s Kitchen, a standalone instrumental and one of the highlights of an album whose songs fit together less naturally than they did on earlier records.

12. Systematic Chaos (2007)

On their first album for Roadrunner, Dream Theater open with one half of In the Presence of Enemies and close with the other. In between, the big riffs of Constant Motion give a good sense of the sound the band were after. There are some impressive passages, though the album as a whole lacks the balance of their best work.

11. A View From The Top Of The World (2021)

James LaBrie begins work on the album over video calls from Canada. The rest of the band are already in their new studio, where he later joins them to record his vocals. The album holds few surprises, with long compositions that give everyone room to be heard. In 2022, The Alien earns Dream Theater their first Grammy.

10. Distance Over Time (2019)

The band spend the summer under one roof and work in a converted barn studio called the Yonderbarn. After The Astonishing, Dream Theater return to tighter songs. You can hear it from the opening of Untethered Angel. The playing is as technical as ever, and the riffs hit home sooner.

9. A Dramatic Turn of Events (2011)

For the demos of this first album without Mike Portnoy, John Petrucci programmed the drum parts. Mike Mangini kept some of those patterns and had free rein to adapt his parts. From the opening of On the Backs of Angels, there’s no mistaking the way Dream Theater write and play.

8. Octavarium (2005)

Between I Walk Beside You and the 24-minute title track, you could almost think you’d put on a different album. Some songs work better than others. The closing suite is unmistakable within the first few minutes of its long intro, well before the drums come in.

7. Parasomnia (2025)

Mike Portnoy returns behind the kit. With Midnight Messiah, he also contributes his first lyrics to a Dream Theater song since 2009. The band’s familiar playing comes through in places, especially on Night Terror, where heavy riffs give way to a long instrumental section. The record already holds its own alongside several of the band’s landmark albums.

6. Black Clouds & Silver Linings (2009)

On his last studio album before leaving the band, Mike Portnoy writes the lyrics to The Best of Times for his father. John Petrucci, meanwhile, draws The Count of Tuscany from an encounter he had in Tuscany. The band sometimes go overboard, and these two songs show how much room they can make for melody in their longer compositions.

5. Train of Thought (2003)

Dream Theater’s heaviest songs go over so well live that the band decide to make an album in that vein. They write it in three weeks and slip a clip from the film Magnolia into Honor Thy Father. The guitars are right up front. All that heaviness can wear you out over the course of the album. It’s also what you come to this record for.

4. Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence (2002)

The first disc moves from subject to subject, from alcoholism to loss of faith. The title track takes up the entire second disc. Across eight parts and 42 minutes, it follows six people dealing with mental health disorders. The shifts in mood from track to track make this an album that takes time to get to know.

3. Awake (1994)

Two years after Images And Words, Dream Theater release a markedly darker record. The arrangements grow denser as the album builds toward Space-Dye Vest, Kevin Moore’s piano-led closer. It’s the band’s last studio album with the keyboardist, and their later records never quite recapture that song’s atmosphere.

2. Images And Words (1992)

James LaBrie’s arrival changes Dream Theater’s sound. Their radio breakthrough comes with Pull Me Under, a song that runs for more than eight minutes and ends abruptly. Years later, the chorus still comes to mind long before the finer points of the instrumental passages.

1. Metropolis Pt. 2: Scenes from a Memory (1999)

At the start of Regression, there’s a ticking sound, followed by Terry Brown’s voice in the role of a hypnotherapist. Dream Theater take their time setting up the story before launching into some of their most spectacular passages. Even when the band are playing at full tilt, the story is easy to follow, right through the instrumental tracks.

What’s your rating?

Share your opinion on the music behind the story.

FROM THE COMMUNITY

The conversation 0

Different voices. A shared love of heavy music.

Be the first to share your thoughts.

What stands out to you? Start the conversation.

Join the conversation

Keep it thoughtful and respectful. Comments are reviewed before appearing.